Exploring the Contrast Between CompactLogix and ControlLogix PLCs

Exploring the Contrast Between CompactLogix and ControlLogix PLCs

Rockwell Automation is a leading brand in industrial automation, offering a diverse range of products catering from small PLCs to large IoT modules. Rockwell's PLCs are renowned for their robust hardware architecture and user-friendly programming software. Among the popular PLCs with large I/O capability are CompactLogix and ControlLogix. In this article, we will delve into the dissimilarities between CompactLogix and ControlLogix PLC brands.

ControlLogix vs CompactLogix

CompactLogix is categorized by Rockwell as a small control system, while ControlLogix is classified as a large control system. This distinction implies that ControlLogix possesses more advanced IO handling, memory, and other software features tailored for large control systems compared to CompactLogix PLC.

CompactLogix PLC

PLC Model Numbers

  • CompactLogix 5370 – starting with the 1769 series
  • CompactLogix 5380 – starting with the 5069 series
  • CompactLogix 5480 – starting with the 5069 series
  • ControlLogix 5570 – starting with the 1756 series
  • ControlLogix 5580 – starting with the 1756 series

Memory Capacity

ControlLogix boasts a maximum memory capacity of 40MB, while CompactLogix reaches up to 20MB.

Number Of Embedded Ethernet Ports

ControlLogix can have a maximum of two embedded Ethernet ports, whereas CompactLogix supports up to three embedded Ethernet ports.

Redundancy

ControlLogix offers redundancy capabilities, which are absent in CompactLogix PLC. Thus, systems requiring redundancy must utilize ControlLogix PLC.

Display System

ControlLogix features a display system providing diagnostic and troubleshooting data. In contrast, CompactLogix PLC troubleshooting is primarily through LEDs. Consequently, ControlLogix offers enhanced diagnostic viewing capabilities.

Communication Protocols Supported

ControlLogix supports Ethernet/IP, ControlNet, DeviceNet, Remote I/O, SyncLink, and USB. On the other hand, CompactLogix supports EthernetI/P, USB, and DeviceNet.

ControlLogix PLCs

Sercos Motion Support

ControlLogix PLC supports the Sercos motion communication standard, widely used in machine automation projects, a feature not available in CompactLogix PLC.

I/O Points Support

ControlLogix PLC supports a maximum of 128,000 digital and 4,000 analog IOs, surpassing CompactLogix PLC.

Integrated Displayport

CompactLogix PLC integrates a display port enabling connection to industrial monitors with high definition, a feature absent in ControlLogix PLC.

Conclusion

While ControlLogix PLC has inherent advantages due to its large-system capabilities, both PLCs offer numerous similar features suitable for harsh, critical, and large industrial environments. Thus, the choice between CompactLogix and ControlLogix depends on specific project requirements and scalability needs.

Show All
Blog posts
Show All
Bridging Allen-Bradley ControlLogix to Yokogawa CENTUM VP DCS via Modbus TCP: Protocol Mapping and Fault Diagnosis

Bridging Allen-Bradley ControlLogix to Yokogawa CENTUM VP DCS via Modbus TCP: Protocol Mapping and Fault Diagnosis

A hands-on guide for configuring Modbus TCP communication between Rockwell Automation ControlLogix PLCs and Yokogawa CENTUM VP DCS, covering register mapping, timeout tuning, and real-world troubleshooting.
PID Controller Tuning on Yokogawa Centum VP and Foxboro IA: A Field Engineer's Guide

PID Controller Tuning on Yokogawa Centum VP and Foxboro IA: A Field Engineer's Guide

PID tuning on Yokogawa CENTUM VP and Foxboro IA requires platform-specific knowledge of the PID2 block and PIDA block respectively, combined with HART diagnostic data from field instruments. This guide covers loop type classification, step-by-step tuning workflows for both platforms including Ziegler-Nichols closed-loop method and built-in auto-tuners, HART valve positioner and transmitter diagnostics, and practical troubleshooting for oscillating and sluggish loops.
Commissioning Allen-Bradley PowerFlex 525 VFDs on ControlLogix 5580 Over EtherNet/IP: A Complete Field Guide

Commissioning Allen-Bradley PowerFlex 525 VFDs on ControlLogix 5580 Over EtherNet/IP: A Complete Field Guide

Allen-Bradley PowerFlex 525 drives communicate with ControlLogix 5580 over EtherNet/IP using CIP Class 1 implicit messaging for cyclic I/O data. This field guide covers AOP version matching, drive IP configuration via HIM parameter C128-C140, Studio 5000 module addition with RPI and assembly size settings, Logic Command/Status word bit mapping, explicit MSG parameter access, and diagnosis of the three most common faults: F81 Comm Loss, Error 16#0204 connection timeout, and F100 parameter out of range.